Case Study: EPC Is King

Posted by Ad Hustler | Posted in Affiliate Marketing, Case Studies | Posted on 23-12-2008

You may have heard a lot of big names in this industry say that payout of an offer doesn’t matter, EPC is all that matters.  It’s human nature to think that the offer with the bigger payout will make you more money.  Duh, seems like common sense right?  Unfortunately, common sense doesn’t always prevail in affiliate marketing.

What is EPC?
Earnings Per Click.

How is EPC determined?
Take the total amount you made on an offer and divide it by the amount of clicks it took to make that much money.  For instance let’s say you run an offer that pays out $10. Let’s also assume you convert 1 in 50 clicks to a lead.  Your EPC will be 20 cents ($10 divided by 50 clicks = 0.20). Pretty simple math and most networks do this for you automatically in their reporting interfaces.

So now that we are all on the same page about what EPC is and how to calculate it, here’s the question.  Let’s say you run the exact same offer at 2 different networks with the exact same payout.  Will the EPC be the same?  Technically it should be, but in practice, is it really?

I decided to do a small case study to find out:

12/19/08
Network A: 0.12 Cents EPC
Network B: 0.07 Cents EPC

12/20/08
Network A: 0.13 Cents EPC
Network B: 0.08 Cents EPC

12/21/08
Network A: 0.14 Cents EPC
Network B: 0.10 Cents EPC

12/22/08
Network A: 0.14 Cents EPC
Network B: 0.09 Cents EPC

12/23/08
Network A: 0.12 Cents EPC
Network B: 0.08 Cents EPC

Consistently, the offer on Network A performed better then the offer on Network B.  Keep in mind, same offer, same payout.  It sounds weird, but this can happen with any offer on any network.  A 4-5 cent difference in EPC can add up big time if you are sending tons of traffic to the offer.  At 5,000 clicks per day you can make an additional $200-$250 per day on the offer just by running it at the network with the better EPC.  Just because Network A performed better on this test, DOES NOT mean that every offer of theirs will perform better split tested against Network B.  There are tons of variables that can effect the performance of an offer on a network.

The lesson learned should be pretty simple.  Always split test the offer you are running with the same offer on other networks.  You could be leaving a lot of money on the table by running an offer that is underperforming the same offer on another network.

Ad Hustler

PPV Case Study #1

Posted by Ad Hustler | Posted in Ad Networks, Case Studies | Posted on 26-11-2008

I tried a small test on a popular PPV network.

Targeting

Country: U.S.
Keywords/URL’s: 4
Budget: $25

Traffic

Views: 1,168
Cost: $22.80
Average CPV: 0.0195 cents

Revenue

Leads Generated: 7
CPA: $1.25
Gross Revenue: $8.75

Net Revenue: -$14.05

My first test was not a winner but not a complete disaster either.  I got a feel for how the system works and what type of traffic comes through.  The conversion rate was rather low but I have a feeling it always is on the low side considering its adware traffic.  To get this right I’m pretty sure that I will need to test a lot of different niches.  One thing I want to try is an offer that pays out better then a buck or two.  Since the conversion rate is low, a higher paid offer may do well for ROI, if targeted correctly.

Ad Hustler

AdEngage Case Study #4

Posted by Ad Hustler | Posted in Ad Networks, Affiliate Marketing, Case Studies | Posted on 13-11-2008

Targeting

Language: English
Region: United States
Demographic: Teen

Traffic & Cost

Click Price: 0.11
Total Clicks Purchased: 1224
Total Cost: $134.64

Offer Results

Offer Payout: $7
Total Leads: 12
Total Revenue: $84
Conversion Rate: 0.98%
Net Profit: -$50.64

Debriefing

This Ad Engage test has proven similar conversion rates as the other tests.  The ad has ran on a similar mix of sites and is still not profitable.  To make this profitable I have a few options:

1) Get cheaper clicks
2) Get a better payout
3) Target only the sites that are converting to leads.

I am going to work on getting a better payout and targeting the sites that are converting to leads.  I plan on doing 2 tests.  I can’t get a better payout on the offer that I’m running.  What I will do is switch offers to another offer I know converts, pays out $2 more and converts a bit better.  Then I will see if that turns the campaign profitable.  I will also take the current offer and place it on the sites on the AdEngage network that I found to be profitable during my other tests.  Assuming the site owners take my ads, I will report back as to whether that is a profitable approach.

Since a lot of ad networks are essentially a black box when you do a run of network buy, Ive decided to show you some of the sites that I’ve gotten as referrers during my tests.  I hope this will help you better analyze the quality of the sites on the AdEngage network:

womeninslips.com
dankspot.com
hotbikinigirls.info
64.233.169.104
workethics101.com
juegosn1.com
watfordoutlet.com
downloads.freehobo.com
arcaddiction.com
sikvid.com
fhm-gossip.blogspot.com
justcommentcodes.com
images.bigupload.com
caramelhoneys.com
torrentupdates.com
celebgirlz.com
scotlandforvisitors.com
photoupdates.com
myfreegraphics.com
winks.msn-beta.com
hotwp.blogspot.com
aberatii.com
positivedailynews.com
flashrehab.com
mehyo.com
flyupload.com
captaingamer.com
globalindianz.com
showbiz.com.pk
boredkiller.net
zepped.com
blog.edirectories.info
unigrads.com
tellmewhyfacts.com
free-english-lesson.blogspot.com
hot-rack.blogspot.com
mindchamber.com
ignition500.com
fatpita.net
shittystories.com
reallybored.net
whatpulse.org
smartass.com
arcade.itopsites.com
funforever.net
artupdates.com
video.aberatii.com
msn-beta.com
narutowallpapers.co.uk
tamilmusica.com
gangfightsdump.com
209.85.173.104
knockoutdump.com
videos3.com
needaddys.com
sniperalley.com
insanelyfunny.com
netnewspublisher.com
stylerazzi.blogspot.com
funyoutubevideos.com
funzone.binarythunder.com
dressupgamesite.com
streetfightdump.com
nasey.net
zaffcast.com
muzika.50webs.com
girlfightsdump.com
myspears.com
schoolfightsdump.com
billiardsarcade.com
cafetinh.net
coolbuddy.com
ads.madisonavenue.com
hqindex.com
gamesilly.com
proarcadegames.com
imboredatwork.net
wiredreality.com
wowshocking.com
boredatwork.net
free-3gp-video.com
free-online-games-player.co.uk
unitednothing.net
idletard.com
kendra-wilkinson.photos-pics.com
girlsareskanks.com
30metri.com
yallaclip.com
funnynfun.com
xnarx.com
multiutils.com
nsfw.glamzilla.com
mmafightdump.com
freakshowplanet.com
imagedaddy.com
heavymag.com
justcomments.com
funtasticus.com
cc.msnscache.com
freehobo.com
jokes-time.com
ghettofightsdump.com
boredusa.com
zoopgames.com
allfunlinks.com
realwarvideos.com
gameabode.com
dailypictures.info
funnycorner.net
allinnone.com
dumpspud.com
fubarvideos.com
sexy-n-funny.com
wallpaperspecials.com
freegameheaven.com
youtube.relaxandenjoy.org
humor-video.com
cinema-stars.com
gorillafights.com
explosivefightvideos.com
plsthx.com
justbulletins.com
boomclips.com
twistedgaia.com
accppna.com
hotlinkspace.com
girlfightsclips.com
airsoftforum.com
shwedream.com
eatliver.com
sexyenjoyment.com
toxicsnot.com
getfansub.com
evilhumor.com
hadeseh.com
play2day.net
s2.thewrestlinggame.com
bigupload.com
netchannels.tv
onlyaddictinggames.com
thatvideodump.com
gamersattack.com
gorillamask.net
100000freecliparts.com
gamefunonline.com
donandmurph.com
yourviralvideos.com
comegetyousome.com
mydressupgame.com
zuuble.com
psfights.com
fuhnee.com
dudehelp.com
shockinghumor.com
ebarcade.com
bigbadblob.com
playboygame.net
kickassmovies.com
shooshtime.com
gamerslevel.com
menspulse.com
flazzy.com
gamesforgirlsclub.com
videoshare.bigupload.com
13gb.com
evilchili.com
tooshocking.com
2spare.com
simplymachine.com
joostick.com
gamestrix.com
playgamesclub.com
videospud.com
clicks.adengage.com
vidfights.com
bloodygames.net
blanny.com
nearlygood.com
planetvids.com
miiwiigames.com
youthink.com
dopegamers.com
lennysgarage.com
humorfights.com
quiztron.com
gameshot.org
traffic.tcmagnet.com
relaxandenjoy.org
gamewalrus.com
buzzhumor.com
zanyvideos.com
doodie.com
toxicjunction.com
[no referer]
i-am-bored.com
youtubebestvideos.com
collegeslackers.com
afunnysite.com
humorexperiments.com
kimbo-fights.com
aimini.net
fishfreegames.com
cdn-i-am-bored.com
vidicafe.com
tokenhumor.com
machovideo.com
hottestvideos.tv
vidbang.com
funnypictures.tv
damnfunnypictures.com
fighttips.com
ufcdump.com
pcgame4fun.com
watchfightvideos.com
glamzilla.com
funnyyoutubevideo.com

Ad Hustler

AdEngage Case Study #3

Posted by Ad Hustler | Posted in Ad Networks, Affiliate Marketing, Case Studies | Posted on 12-11-2008

Targeting

Language: English
Region: United States
Demographic: Teen

Traffic & Cost

Click Price: 0.11
Total Clicks Purchased: 2283
Total Cost: $251.13

Offer Results

Offer Payout: $7 (Got A Payout Bump - Same Offer As AdEngage Case Study #2)
Total Leads: 16
Total Revenue: $112
Conversion Rate: 0.70%
Net Profit: -$139.13

Debriefing

As I suspected, the results were not consistent.  My conversion rate was way lower. then case study #2.  Even with a .50 cent payout bump, I did not turn a profit on this test.  Total loss was $139.13.  One thing I am finding about these Ad Engage tests is that certain sites on the network perform a whole lot better then others.  Since I track everything, I can see which sites these are and possibly buy just those sites through Ad Engage.  The only issue with this is that by buying individual sites, you can not target a specific countries traffic only.  This means you may be wasting a rather large portion of the clicks you buy to traffic that is untargeted to your offer.  I am not done with Ad Engage and will post the results of any other tests I decide to do.

Ad Hustler

AdEngage Case Study #2

Posted by Ad Hustler | Posted in Affiliate Marketing, Case Studies | Posted on 11-11-2008

Ad Engage is a tough nut to crack.  Here are my results from case study #2

Targeting

Language: English
Region: United States
Demographic: Teen

Traffic & Cost

Click Price: 0.11
Total Clicks Purchased: 1,438
Total Cost: $158.18

Offer Results

Offer Payout: $6.50
Total Leads: 26
Total Revenue: $169
Conversion Rate: 1.8%
Net Profit: $10.82

Debriefing

This test was not too bad for early experimentation.  I didn’t lose money which is always a positive thing.  I also didn’t make much money on a $158 spend.  Margins are definetly a lot tighter on Ad Engage then on a lot of other traffic sources I have used.  My explanation for this is that since it’s a ‘content network’ type ad network with very little targeting, you are getting a mix of complete junk clicks and OK quality clicks.  At 0.11 cents street rate the traffic is priced on the high side.  I am going to do another test to see if the results are consistent.  My guess is that it’s going to be completely inconsistent because of the variety of sites the ad will be placed on.  We shall see.

Ad Hustler